ASU

Get Pizza by the Slice at these Tempe Restaurants

Find your favorite slice of pizza at these Tempe restaurants

We don’t know about you, but we think pizza is always a good idea. It is typically a weekly, or let’s be honest, almost daily, part of our diet. These pizza joints in Tempe have stolen a pizza of our hearts and we think you need to discover your favorite slice, whether it be traditional or trending towards unusual. Sadly for us, we didn’t get to try every slice of pizza in Tempe (but we will), so we’ve compiled a list of the places that we did try below. That’s not where the list ends, however. You can also get pizza slices (for lunch) at Sacred Pi or Barro’s in south Tempe. Gus’s New York Pizza is another local favorite and just steps from the ASU Tempe Campus, they have the distinction of being open 24 hours a day. Or check out 414 Pizza in Downtown Tempe for good eats and a side of nightly karaoke. You gotta love that pizza places are aplenty in college towns like Tempe. 

We’re going to try to keep the pizza puns to a minimum because they’re so cheesy but we can’t help but share these slices of heaven with you. After you read this, you’re going to want a pizza this! 

Venezia’s Pizza
27 E. Southern Ave., Tempe, AZ 85282 | (480) 858-1660 

Venezia’s has a few locations in the metro area, including one in Tempe on Mill and Southern Avenues. Their friendly staff serves up pizza by the slice for lunch and dinner. You can pair a slice or two with salad or wings and a drink. Their hearty slices are New York style, so expect a thinner crust and lots of gooey cheese. And, their Tempe location is big, so there’s lot of room for you, your squad and the pizza loving masses.  

Signature slice: The Mala, inspired by the Phoenix Rising Football Club, is topped with cheese, pepperoni, grilled chicken and French fries. You can also add a Buffalo sauce swirl, bacon and jalapenos. Because, why wouldn’t you? 

Sal’s Pizza
922 E. Apache Blvd., Tempe, AZ 85281 | (480) 248-9338 

Just a stone’s throw from the ASU Tempe Campus at Rural and Apache, Sal’s Pizza is the choice for a quick lunch or late-night bite (and by late, we mean they’re open until 3 a.m. on Friday and Saturdays). It’s called “wicked good pizza,” because they are straight out of Boston. Their slices are HUGE and their prices are super reasonable.  

Signature slice: It’s a tough call, but we’d go with the barbecue chicken pizza.  

Otto Pizza and Pastry
804 S. Ash Ave. Tempe, AZ 85281 | 480-966-1003 

Otto Pizza and Pastry is a cozy little place that’s been serving up whole pies and slices for more than 27 years. Otto (who moved to Arizona from France in 1992) can always be found in the kitchen kneading the dough for his tasty New York-style pizza. The generously sized slices start at $2.39 with additional toppings costing 59 cents. Deal! And, your order will be out in just minutes.  It’s close to ASU, making it a perfect spot for busy, budget-minded students.  

Signature slice: Otto Rainbow covers the spectrum with mozzarella, pepperoni, ham, green pepper, black olives, tomatoes and seasonings.   

Slices – A Unique Style Pizza Joint

Downtown Tempe
11 E. 6th Street, Tempe, AZ 85281 | (480) 966-4681 

Tempe Marketplace
2000 E. Rio Salado Pkwy., Tempe, AZ 85281 | (480) 966-2021   

Dare I say “Slices – A Unique Style Pizza Joint” is Tempe’s little slice of heaven or is that too CHEESY? When Slices first opened, it was their goal to bring a “slice” of urban living to the Sonoran Desert. Now with two Tempe locations, one on Mill Avenue and 6th Street and the other inside Tempe Marketplace, Slices is bringing the best college and nightlife pizza joint to the forefront. It should be obvious at this point that you can grab pizza by the slice here, but you can also splurge on a 16” or 19” pie or create your own calzone. Beginners tip: If you do order by the slice, get there at the beginning of the lunch hour as their options go fast!  

 Signature slice: Potato & Bacon is a winner every time. I mean how can you go wrong with those toppings? 

NYPD Pizza
222 S. Mill Ave., # 127, Tempe, AZ 85281 | (480) 970-6973 

This lunchtime favorite and building neighbor offers you pizza by the pie or by the slice. We LOVE their lunch combo options. “Gimme a Wall Street and Brooklyn with a pop.”  Channeling our inner New Yorker is super easy here with a modern yet vintage feel. Dine in for lunch or grab it quickly with counter service. If you’re trying to watch your carb consumption *insert eye roll*, you can grab a pizza slice with a side salad or even half dozen boneless wings your way… It’s kind of healthy… right? Justification is key. After 4 p.m., slices switch to half price – a great stop on your way home. 

Signature Slice: The Wallstreet is a good choice for meat lovers, pepperoni, sausage and bacon and to make it healthy… mushrooms! Yummy! 

Spinelli’s Pizza
420 S. Mill Ave., #101, Tempe, AZ 85281 | (602) 800-5300 

As pizza lovers, we want all the carbs of course, but sometimes pizza slices are a little too much bread (said no one ever). So when you’re ready to take on a slice of flavor town, hit up one of our favorite late night/early morning snack stops, Spinelli’s. It’s a great place after hanging out on Mill Avenue or where to be in between acts during @Innings Festival or other events at Tempe Beach Park. We love their wide variety of pizza slice types that make you question the taste but you somehow think it makes sense… Chicken and Waffles… Chicken Bacon Ranch… Breakfast…. Mac N Cheese… Now these all sound a bit crazy but definitely give them a try. You can thank us later.

Signature Slice: Give us an ultra-thin slice of Veggie pizza please and enjoy every bit of the toppings because you won’t be overwhelmed by the thickness of crust. 

What’s your favorite pizza topping? Tell us in the comments.

Thanks for reading – share with your friends!

Don’t forget to tag us in your photos! Use #OurTempe and @TempeTourism on Instagram and Twitter.

Rachel Semik
Written Rachel Semik

Lover of all things social media and staying in the know, you'll find Content Strategist/ASU Alumni, Rachel out devouring ice cream sandwiches and tasting her way through Tempe's margarita scene.